Taps and Timers
Games

Epic Games challenges Apple's 27% external payment commission in Supreme Court appeal

Epic Games has filed its Supreme Court brief, arguing Apple was correctly held in contempt for imposing a 27% fee on open web purchases and restricting payment links, a move developers say makes external options more expensive than Apple's own 30% rate.

Epic Games has filed its Supreme Court brief, arguing Apple was correctly held in contempt for imposing a 27% fee on open...

Epic Games has submitted its legal brief to the US Supreme Court contesting Apple's 27% commission on external payment links as a violation of the 2021 injunction. The company argues Apple was correctly held in contempt of court over its iPhone app payment rules. Epic Games stated that Apple started charging a 27% junk fee on purchases made on the open web and then made it nearly impossible for customers to link out to make those purchases.

Epic Games filed its official response to Apple's brief, arguing that Apple devised a plan to circumvent the injunction. The company claims the 27% commission rate, combined with developers' own payment-handling costs of more than 3%, makes linked-out purchases more expensive than Apple's standard 30% in-app purchase rate. Epic described this as a calculated scheme to evade the injunction, planned by top management. The 27% commission on open web purchases was so high that developers would lose money if users paid outside Apple's system.

Court of appeals upholds contempt finding against Apple

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals confirmed Apple was held in civil contempt. The court upheld the contempt ruling for implementing new restrictions that undermined the original injunction's purpose. It found Apple violated the order by implementing rules that effectively restricted steering to alternative payment methods. The ruling stated that a reasonable person reading the injunction’s terms in light of its context and purposes would see Apple's actions as an attempt to circumvent the injunction through alternative means.

Epic Games stated that the district court had held Apple in contempt, finding it had attempted a bad-faith cover-up. This included presenting a sham report to justify the 27% fee. Epic also alleged Apple tried to cover up its scheme by asserting privilege over more than 57,000 documents. The company cited Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers' finding that Apple's Vice President of Finance outright lied under oath about when Apple decided to impose the new commission.

Apple argues injunction does not prohibit external commissions

Apple maintains the original court order never explicitly banned commissions on external purchases or additional payment link restrictions. The company said the injunction's text did not mention commissions, a point the Ninth Circuit itself recognised. Apple argues that Epic had conceded the district court did not explicitly ban a new fee on purchases made outside an app.

Apple contends it should not be held in contempt for conduct the court order did not clearly prohibit. The company said it strongly and respectfully disagrees with the district court's findings and had devoted enormous resources to complying. Apple argued that contempt is among the most potent powers a federal court can use and that for over 140 years, a party could only be held in civil contempt if there was no fair ground of doubt it had violated an order.

The U.S. government argued the original injunction did not clearly prohibit Apple's 27% commission on external purchases. However, it maintained Apple was correctly held in contempt for restricting how developers could display external payment buttons.

Legal timeline shows escalating court battles

The legal battle began in 2020 when Epic sued Apple after Fortnite was removed for bypassing Apple's In-App Purchase system. A federal court ruled in 2021 that Apple must allow developers to direct users to alternative payment methods outside the App Store, but imposed a 27% commission on external purchases and new restrictions on displaying payment buttons.

Apple appealed the contempt ruling to the Supreme Court in May 2026, and the Court agreed to hear the case in June 2026. Apple submitted its opening brief in September 2026, followed by supporting briefs from the U.S. government, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Chamber of Progress, and several former federal antitrust enforcers.

Apple has until December 14 to submit its final brief before oral arguments are scheduled for January 11, 2027.

Topics

#Games

Related coverage

More from Games